“Had Its Moments, But Mostly a Disappointment”

The Testament by John Grisham

I’m not sure what I was expecting from this. Someone told me that anyone familiar with the law would see how poor Grisham’s books were, legally speaking. I’ve only had a year of law school, but I didn’t notice anything glaringly wrong with the legal material. All of the problems were with everything else.

The story starts out interestingly enough – an eccentric billionaire commits suicide and leaves nothing to his spoiled children. He leaves everything to an illegitimate daughter who is working as a missionary in South America, but who wants nothing to do with the 11 billion dollars. What ensues is a legal battle for the ages.

The best parts of the story are all about the legal maneuvering. There is a 20 page span concerning the depositions where Grisham hits his stride. Essentially, anything relating to law is where the book is strong. Anything relating to character depth and anything emotional is poorly done, even formulaic. He did not even need to bother with the ending since it had been telegraphed for so long.

Gone are the days where Grisham was the master of the legal thriller. This book is one of the many that have grown a part of his slow descent…